What struck me the most about seeing RotK was how detached I was through the whole thing. Perhaps it was because I’d read the spoilers and was watching for particular events; perhaps it was just that the film hardly drew me in at all. Oh, there were scenes that moved me, but even then I was watching in thought mode rather than feel mode.
Spoilers below….
My very favorite bit in the entire LotR book trilogy is at the battle of the Pelennor Fields, when Eomer looks out across the fields and sees the ships of the Corsairs of Umbar sailing up the river. For a moment he feels despair, knowing that these reinforcements will strengthen the enemy beyond any hope. But he rallies himself, and raises his sword in defiance. And as he does so, a banner unfurls on the lead ship, a black banner bearing a white tree and seven stars around it — the banner of the King of Gondor. And Eomer realizes that the ships bear friends, and he rejoices.
So I’m really annoyed that PJ didn’t do this scene in the movie.
But I did like the bit with running the sword along the spears. And the beacon lighting. And the whole Mount Doom scene.