I’ve used TMG for almost the entire time I’ve done serious genealogy. I first bought it when they only had a DOS version, and later was happy for many years with their Windows version 3.5.
Then came the Feline Suicide Attempt — “if I barf a hairball on this laptop, maybe the human will defenestrate me!”
I got a new laptop, but the TMG CD I have is only version 3.0 — the higher versions were downloads that, of course, aren’t available anymore. So I finally decided to upgrade — except that the upgrade price is ridiculous; it was cheaper to just buy a new Silver Edition.
While I’ve only taken one trip to the genealogy library with it, I’m already very grateful that I spent only $39 on this thing and not the $89 for the “upgrade”.
Yes, the new layout flexibility is very nice. Yes, it’s very helpful to see a person’s children and siblings on the same screen. Yes, I love being able to accent based on multiple flags. Yes, I’m happy about the special upgrade I bought for Gedstar, that creates my Palm genealogy database directly from my TMG files. I suspect that the multiple data sets within one project is a very nifty feature, though I haven’t yet had occasion to try it.
But dear gods, can they make the thing any clunkier to use?
It’s SLOW. I hit a tag or a flag and can usually count to five before I get the window. Okay, some of this is my laptop; I’ve tried it on the desktop machine, which has a slightly faster processor and a little more memory; there it runs a little faster. But even on the desktop, it still takes three hours to generate a GEDCOM of my 20K person database; Family Tree Maker can generate one from that sized database in half an hour tops. And if I have to do my primary genealogy computer work on the desktop, then I’ll have to do a lot less of it, because I can’t use the desktop and watch my son at the same time
They took out a lot of the keystrokes. Used to be that I could get to a person’s mother with Alt-S[earch]-M[other]; now I have to use the mouse. For a speed typist like me, that’s not an improvement. (They changed several others, which is better than completely deleting them but is still taking time to get used to — and why switch “close this window” from F10 to F9 anyway? Why does F10 need to be “go to the menu bar” when the Alt key does the same thing?)
There’s a bug that keeps you from generating reports, even just printed to a file or to change flags, if you don’t have a printer installed. I don’t want to install a printer on my laptop just so that this program will function completely.
And given that the big strength of TMG is their citations, why the FLOCCULATION is the citation on a separate tab from the tag information???? It’s not like the screen real estate is that limited, even on my laptop! And you have to use the fricking MOUSE to access the tab; you can’t get to it by a keystroke! What are they smoking at WhollyGenes? Whenever I go to the genealogy library to scour censuses, I’m not going to even try entering the data directly into TMG. I’m just going to copy it into Word, and enter it into TMG later, because this library ain’t open forever, and in the time it’ll take me to enter ONE person I can copy information for a family of six!
Version 5.0.9 is LESS usuable than version 3.5 was. And that’s extremely disappointing, to say the least.
Yeah, I’ll probably still stick with the thing for now. Family Tree Maker, while its source handling has massively improved, still has that obnoxious four-children block at the bottom. I’m not familiar with another PC program that does what I want any better, and I’m not quite ready to go installing Linux on my laptop just so I can try out Gramps.
But it’s so damn frustrating, that a program I’ve long loved is now so cumbersome to use that I really wouldn’t recommend it to anyone.